Saturday, August 9, 2008

Pre-Plan Statistics - August 10

Let's provide a little perspective for future reference. All numbers below reflect calculations for clerks reported by August 10. (I hope to follow up occasionally at different stages of the process.)

Federal judges are supposed to follow "the plan," which means they are not even supposed to receive applications until September 2, 2008. Yet 136 federal appellate clerks have already been hired for 2009-2010. A breakdown is below.



While just 23 appellate clerks are 3Ls, a whopping 101 clerks are graduates. Which judges have definitely hired 3Ls so far? (Remember, not all hires may be listed on this site.)

King (4), Benavides (5), Smith (5), Southwick (5), Posner (7), Ikuta (9), Kozinski (9), Gorsuch (10), Hartz (10), Henry (10), Kelly (10), Tymkovich (10), Ebel Sr. (10), Dubina (11), Pryor (11), Cox Sr. (11)

Of course, the Second Circuit already has 18 graduates as clerks (not including, of course, unreported clerks and unknown clerks); the Third Circuit, 16; the Fifth Circuit, 11; the Ninth Circuit, 17; and the DC Circuit, 10.

Contrast that to the Tenth Circuit, which, while hiring just four graduates reported so far, has nine 3Ls. Or the Eleventh, with just four graduates reported so far but five 3Ls.

(Take all analyses with a grain of salt; recall that incomplete data may skew what has been reported. These statistics, at the very least, represent a minimum.)

Which schools have pushed their graduates most successfully before August 10? It's uncertain the effect a school's career services office may have on graduates--are graduates left on their own, or does career services help facilitate graduate clerkship placement? Chicago has six graduates so far; Columbia, four; Georgetown, nine; GWU, four; Harvard, 10; NYU, nine; Stanford, six; Virginia, 11; and Yale, six.

Which schools offer a helping hand if you want to go off-plan before August 10? So far, Harvard has at least four 3Ls placed, and Duke and Michigan each have three 3Ls placed. (None have been reported from Yale, Columbia, or NYU; and one each from Stanford and Chicago.)

Wednesday, June 18, 2008

2010-2011 hires

Please put hires for 2010-2011 here. These will be saved for next year's list.

Thursday, May 8, 2008

Clerks by school

137 clerks as of August 9 (list does not include clerks serving a second year)

Alabama (1): Dubina (11)
American (1): Sloviter (3)
Ave Maria (1): Smith (3)
Berkeley (1): Williams Sr. (DC)
Boston College (2): Cabranes (2), Wesley (2)
Brooklyn (1): Greenberg Sr. (3)
Chicago (7): Elrod (5), Elrod (5), Bybee (9), Kozinski (9), Clifton (9), McKeown (9), Williams Sr. (DC)
Columbia (4): Chagares (3), Chagares (3), Benavides (5), McKeown (9)
Duke (6): King (4), Rogers (6), Gorsuch (10), Henry (10), Black (11), Pryor (11)
Faulkner (1): Carnes (11)
Fordham (3): Katzmann (2), Hartz (10), Kelly (10)
Georgetown (12): Torruella (1), Katzmann (2), Wesley (2), Chagares (3), Fisher (3), Fuentes (3), Roth Sr. (3), Garza (5), Smith (5), McKeown (9), Brown (DC), Tatel (DC)
Georgia (3): Carnes (11), Dubina (11), Cox Sr. (11)
Golden Gate (1): Bea (9)
GWU (4): King (4), Williams (4), Gibbons (6), Moore (Fed)
Harvard (19): Boudin (1), Ambro (3), Garth Sr.(3), Roth Sr. (3), Duncan (4), Duncan (4), Clement (5), Elrod (5), Moore (6), Posner (7), Callahan (9), Ikuta (9), Kozinski (9), Paez (9), Gorsuch (10), Gorsuch (10), Brown (DC), Kavanaugh (DC), Rogers (DC)
Illinois (1): Silverman (9)
Iowa (1): Moore (6)
Maryland (2): Motz (4), Bybee (9)
Michigan (6): Walker Sr. (2), Smith (5), Gould (9), Tymkovich (10), Pryor (11), Garland (DC)
Mississippi College (1): Southwick (5)
North Dakota (1): Bright Sr. (8)
Northwestern (4): Winter Sr. (2), Garza (5), Kozinski (9), M. Smith (9)
Notre Dame (1): Kelly (10)
NYU (10): Jacobs (2), Katzmann (2), Sotomayor (2), Walker Sr. (2), Fuentes (3), Fuentes (3), Rendell (3), Greenberg Sr. (3), Rogers (DC), Edwards Sr. (DC)
Penn (4): Wesley (2), Walker Sr. (2), Rendell (3), Rendell (3)
Rutgers-Camden (1): Greenberg Sr. (3)
St. Louis (1): Murphy (10)
Samford (1): Dubina
Stanford (7): Parker (2), Sotomayor (2), Ikuta (9), D. Nelson Sr. (9), Marcus (11), Rogers (DC), Linn (Fed.)
Texas Tech (1): Benavides (5)
Tulane (1): Kozinski (9)
UCLA (3): Pregerson (9), Reinhardt (9), M. Smith (9)
Utah (1): Murphy (10)
Vanderbilt (2): Gilman (6), Gorsuch (10)
Virginia (10): Jacobs (2), King (4), Niemeyer (4), Clement (5), Clement (5), Clement (5), Daughtrey (6), Gilman (6), Merritt Sr. (6), Black (11)
W&L (2): Cowan Sr. (3), Elrod (5)
W&M (2): Silverman (9), Kelly (10)
WUSTL (1): Ebel (10)
Yale (6): Katzmann (2), Raggi (2), Sack (2), Wilkinson (4), Fisher (9), Williams Sr. (DC)

Thursday, April 10, 2008

Welcome!

A new year means a new set of clerks! Apart from the general provisions below, I wanted to draw your attention to a couple of items.

First, I'd like to track which clerks are graduates (marked in italics) as opposed to clerks that are hired as 3Ls for the year after their graduation. Please let me know if the clerk hired is a "graduate" or "3L." Unknown clerks will be underlined.

Second, feel free to correct me, particularly in these early stages. Among other things, I'm working from last year's list of which judges (generally senior) who don't hire clerks or have only career clerks. Those lists may change, but right now I have the working list of them designated as "none" below. Additionally, if you know of a judge who's passed away, been recently confirmed, or has taken senior status, please let me know if I've failed to update the page.

Tuesday, April 1, 2008

About this blog

I've only included clerks hired this year. A two-year clerk in the second year of a clerkship for 2009-2010, for instance, would not be included [but a clerk working a second year would be bracketed]. A career clerk would not be listed.

Feel free to post anonymously. It's not the most readable format, but if you search using Ctrl+F, it makes it extremely easy to find the information you want, all on one page. It's also easy for me to edit, and I don't have to host a Web page.

If possible, please report whether the clerk hired is a Class of 2009 law school student or a clerk who has graduated earlier. Graduate clerks are designated with a school name in italics.

Do not confuse this site with the Clerkship Notification Blog. This site is not intended to be a resource for information on which judges are hiring or who has begun interviewing. It is only intended to log which judges have hired from which schools. Judges who did not hire (or are reported as not expecting to hire) any clerks this term (e.g., some senior judges, those with only career clerks) are so noted. Inactive judges are not listed.

Do not tell me that I'm missing information or about how inaccurate my information is. If it's inaccurate and you can correct the errata, then tell me what to correct and I'll do so. If it's inaccurate but you have no factual information that can remedy the errata, save some anecdotal evidence of "at least a dozen" people who're clerking, or that "I can think of at least three that aren't listed," but you fail to name who they're clerking for, I'll ignore your comments. It's utterly unproductive.

This site focuses solely on federal appellate clerks. There are numerous other resources for Supreme Court clerks, and it does not track staff attorneys. It also looks only at clerks who will work the 2009-2010 term.

Friday, March 28, 2008

1st Circuit

Boudin: Harvard
Torruella: Georgetown
Campbell (Sr.): None
Cyr (Sr.): None

Unavailable: Howard, Lipez, Lynch, Selya (Sr.), Stahl (Sr.)

2d Circuit

Cabranes: Boston College
Jacobs: NYU, Virginia
Katzmann: Fordham, Georgetown, NYU, Yale
Parker: Stanford
Raggi: Yale
Sack: Yale
Sotomayor: NYU, Stanford
Wesley: Boston College, Georgetown, Penn
Walker (Sr.): Michigan, NYU, Penn
Winter (Sr.): Northwestern
Miner (Sr.): None

Unavailable: Calabresi, Feinberg, Hall, Livingston, Pooler, Straub, Cardamone (Sr.), Feinberg (Sr.), Kearse (Sr.), Leval (Sr.), McLaughlin (Sr.), Newman (Sr.)

3d Circuit

Ambro: Harvard
Chagares: Columbia, Columbia, Georgetown
Fisher: Georgetown
Fuentes: Georgetown, NYU, NYU
Rendell: NYU, Penn, Penn
Sloviter: American
Smith: Ave Maria
Cowen (Sr.): W&L
Garth (Sr.): Harvard
Greenberg (Sr.): Brooklyn, NYU, Rutgers-Camden
Roth (Sr.): Georgetown, Harvard
Nygaard (Sr.): None

Unavailable: Barry, Hardiman, Jordan, McKee, Scirica, Aldisert (Sr.), Stapleton (Sr.), Van Antwerpen (Sr.), Weis (Sr.)

4th Circuit

Agee: [Richmond], [W&M]
Duncan: Harvard, Harvard
King: Duke, GWU, Virginia
Motz: Maryland
Niemeyer: Virginia
Wilkinson: Yale
Williams: GWU
Traxler: None
Hamilton (Sr.): None
Wilkins (Sr.): None

Unavailable: Gregory, Michael, Shedd,

5th Circuit

Benavides: Columbia, Texas Tech
Clement: Harvard, Virginia, Virginia, Virginia
Elrod: Chicago, Chicago, Harvard, W&L
Garza: Georgetown, Northwestern
Southwick: Mississippi College
Smith: Georgetown, Michigan

Unavailable: Barksdale, Davis, Dennis, Haynes, Jolly, Jones, King, Owen, Prado, Stewart, Wiener, DeMoss (Sr.), Duhé (Sr.), Garwood (Sr.), Higginbotham (Sr.), Reavley (Sr.)

6th Circuit

Daughtrey: Virginia
Gibbons: GWU
Gilman: Vanderbilt, Virginia
Moore: Harvard, Iowa
Rogers: Duke
Merritt (Sr.): Virginia
Guy (Sr.): None
Nelson (Sr.): None
Suhrheinrich (Sr.): None

Unavailable: Batchelder, Boggs, Clay, Cole, Cook, Griffin, Kethledge, Martin, McKeague, Sutton, White, Keith (Sr.), Kennedy (Sr.), Norris (Sr.), Ryan (Sr.), Siler (Sr.)

7th Circuit

Posner: Harvard

Unavailable: Easterbrook, Evans, Flaum, Kanne, Rovner, Sykes, Tinder, Williams, Wood, Bauer (Sr.), Coffey (Sr.), Cudahy (Sr.), Manion (Sr.), Ripple (Sr.)

8th Circuit

Bright (Sr.): North Dakota
Hansen (Sr.): None
Magill (Sr.): None

Unavailable: Benton, Bye, Colloton, Gruender, Loken, Melloy, Murphy, Riley, Shepherd, Smith, Wollman, Arnold (Sr.), Beam (Sr.), Bowman (Sr.), Gibson (Sr.)

9th Circuit

Bea: Golden Gate
Bybee: Chicago, Maryland
Callahan: Harvard
Clifton: Chicago
Fisher: Yale
Gould: Michigan
Ikuta: Harvard, Stanford
Kozinski: Chicago, Harvard, Northwestern, Tulane
McKeown: Chicago, Columbia, Georgetown
Paez: Harvard
Pregerson: UCLA
Reinhardt: UCLA
Silverman: Illinois, W&M
M. Smith: Northwestern, UCLA
D. Nelson (Sr.): Stanford
Boochever (Sr.): None
Leavy (Sr.): None
Skopil (Sr.): None
Trott (Sr.): None

Unavailable: Berzon, W. Fletcher, Graber, Hawkins, Kleinfeld, O'Scannlain, Rawlinson, Rymer, Schroeder, N.R. Smith, Tallman, Thomas, Wardlaw, Alarcon (Sr.), Beezer (Sr.), Browning (Sr.), Brunetti (Sr.), Canby (Sr.), Farris (Sr.), Fernandez (Sr.), B. Fletcher (Sr.), Goodwin (Sr.), Hall (Sr.), Hug (Sr.), T. Nelson (Sr.), Noonan (Sr.), Tashima (Sr.), Thompson (Sr.), Wallace (Sr.)

10th Circuit

Gorsuch: Duke, Harvard, Harvard, Vanderbilt
Hartz: Fordham
Henry: Duke
Kelly: Fordham, Notre Dame, W&M
Murphy: St. Louis, Utah
Tymkovich: Michigan
Ebel (Sr.): WUSTL
Anderson (Sr.): None
Brorby (Sr.): None
Porfilio (Sr.): None

Unavailable: Briscoe, Holmes, Lucero, McConnell, O'Brien, Tacha, Baldock (Sr.), Holloway (Sr.), McKay (Sr.), McWilliams (Sr.), Seymour (Sr.),

11th Circuit

Black: Duke, Virginia
Carnes: Faulkner, Georgia
Dubina: Alabama, Georgia, Samford
Marcus: Stanford
Pryor: Duke, Michigan
Cox (Sr.): Georgia
Hill (Sr.): None

Anderson, Barkett, Birch, Edmondson, Hull, Tjoflat, Wilson, Fay (Sr.), Kravitch (Sr.)

DC Circuit

Brown: Georgetown, Harvard
Garland: Michigan
Kavanaugh: Harvard
Rogers: Harvard, NYU, Stanford
Tatel: Georgetown
Edwards (Sr.): NYU
Williams (Sr.): Berkeley, Chicago, Yale

Unavailable: Ginsburg, Griffith, Henderson, Randolph, Sentelle, Buckley (Sr.), Silberman (Sr.)

Federal Circuit

Linn: Stanford
Moore: GWU
Archer (Sr.): None
Plager (Sr.): None

Unavailable: Bryson, Dyk, Gajarsa, Lourie, Mayer, Michel, Newman, Prost, Rader, Schall, Clevenger (Sr.), Friedman (Sr.)